FOI release

proposed wastewater discharges - Bedburn and Euden watercourse systems

This request was refused in part, so we didn't provide some of the information the requester asked for. This may include information where we can neither confirm nor deny that we hold it.

Case reference EIR2026/52043

Received 21 October 2026

Published 18 November 2026

Request

I seek copies of environmental information held by the Environment Agency concerning its assessment of the proposed wastewater discharges to the Bedburn and Euden watercourse systems for Durham County Council planning application DM/24/02979/FPA, Hamsterley Forest.

This request follows the Environment Agency’s response to my enquiry ENQ2026/47068, dated 19 October 2026. That response states that an EA fisheries specialist reviewed the proposals; effects on salmonid life stages and the proximity of discharges to spawning areas were considered; flow data and Monte Carlo modelling would be used at the environmental-permitting stage; and measures to protect salmonid habitat “have yet to be determined”.

Please provide the following recorded information, for the period 1 October 2024 to 19 October 2026:

1. Fisheries specialist review: The name, role and position within the EA of the Fisheries expert carrying out this assessment, advice, notes, reports, referrals, briefing material or other records documenting the fishery specialist’s review of the proposed discharges, including the date of the review. Please include any record identifying the information or documents considered as part of that review.

2. Salmonid life stages and spawning locations: Records documenting how the EA considered effects on spawning adults, eggs, alevins, fry, parr and migrating smolts, and the information it relied on about known or likely spawning areas near each proposed discharge. This includes relevant maps, fisheriesrecords, survey information, assessment tables or technical advice held by the EA.

3. Advice to the planning authority: Records of advice, comments or correspondence provided to Durham County Council about salmonid impacts, the need for further applicant information, or whether a Salmonid Impact, Mitigation and Monitoring Plan—or equivalent measures—should be submitted or agreed before the planning application is determined. Please include any recorded objections, proposed conditions or reasons for not requesting such a plan. The EA objection logged on the DCC planning portal is limited to say the least.

4. Flow and water-quality information: Existing flow data, hydrological information, model inputs, assumptions, outputs or reviews held by the EA that relate to assessing the proposed discharges at the Bedburn and Euden receiving watercourses. This includes any recorded low-flow or Q95 information and any Monte Carlo modelling already undertaken or reviewed for this proposal. I am not asking the EA to carry out new modelling.

5. Reasons salmonid protection measures remain undetermined: Records identifying or discussing proposed construction restrictions, operational controls, monitoring requirements, thresholds or corrective actions to protect salmonid habitat. Please also provide any recorded reasons or advice explaining why these measures “have yet to be determined”, including any records showing whether this is because:

- further or more complete information from the applicant is required;

- the EA expects the measures to be determined through environmental permitting; or

- another reason applies.

I am seeking existing records that address this issue, not a newly created explanation or assessment.

6. Environmental-permitting process: Records held by the EA of any environmental-permit application or pre-application engagement concerning the proposed discharges, including its status as at 19 October 2026 and any recorded advice about the information or modelling required to assess them.

The request covers relevant records held by the EA’s fisheries, water-quality, hydrology, planning and permitting teams, including relevant correspondence with the applicant, its consultants or Durham County Council.

Response

Thank you for your request for information regarding proposed wastewater discharges - Bedburn and Euden watercourse systems, which we received on 21 October 2026.

We respond to requests for information that we hold under the Environmental Information Regulations 2004 (EIR). The Regulations requires that we respond to requests by advising you whether information is held or not, and if so by providing you with that information.

Your requests and the corresponding answers are set out below.

Information provided

1. Fisheries specialist review:
The name, role and position within the EA of the Fisheries expert carrying out this assessment, advice, notes, reports, referrals, briefing material or other records documenting the fishery specialist’s review of the proposed discharges, including the date of the review. Please include any record identifying the information or documents considered as part of that review.

We have chosen to withhold the name of the individual concerned who holds the position of Fisheries Technical Officer.  Please see the appendix below for further details.

We do not hold any recorded reviews or documented rationale regarding the proposed discharges. Instead, we have reviewed the proposals and formed a view based on our knowledge and experience, drawing on fish survey data and other sources of information, including advice from specialist colleagues who are already objecting to the proposed scheme on water quality grounds.


2. Salmonid life stages and spawning locations:
Records documenting how the EA considered effects on spawning adults, eggs, alevins, fry, parr and migrating smolts, and the information it relied on about known or likely spawning areas near each proposed discharge. This includes relevant maps, fisheries records, survey information, assessment tables or technical advice held by the EA.

Similarly, we do not hold any such records but are fully conversant with the environmental requirements of the various life stages of salmonids and the effects of potential impacts on them.  Regarding information pertaining to “known or likely spawning areas near each proposed discharge”, this includes local knowledge gleaned from walkovers of the areas concerned, as well as the wider Bedburn Beck system, and a redd survey in December 2023 carried out by the applicant at our request.  The results of this survey are set out in Section 3.6 of the “Aquatic Ecology Report” appended to the “Hamsterley Forest Water Framework Directive Screening and Scoping Assessment” report on the planning portal.  Among additional sources of information on juvenile salmonid populations are results from electric fishing surveys carried out both by the applicant to further inform the baseline (as detailed in Section 3.4 of the aforementioned ecology report) and the EA on the Bedburn Beck system historically, which are available via the Ecology & Fish Data Explorer. 

Looking ahead, we plan to resurvey our “Bedburn Beck at Forest Drive” and “Bedburn Beck at Forest Walk Mill” survey sites in 2027. The “Bedburn Beck at Newhall Farm” site is also in the survey programme for 2028.


3. Advice to the planning authority:
Records of advice, comments or correspondence provided to Durham County Council about salmonid impacts, the need for further applicant information, or whether a Salmonid Impact, Mitigation and Monitoring Plan—or equivalent measures—should be submitted or agreed before the planning application is determined. Please include any recorded objections, proposed conditions or reasons for not requesting such a plan. The EA objection logged on the DCC planning portal is limited to say the least. 

As you are aware our full response dated 20 December 2024 is available on Durham County Council’s planning portal: DM/24/02979/FPA | Proposed Masterplan for Hamsterley Forest

Please also find attached the consultee comments in respect of this planning application from our Fisheries, Biodiversity and Geomorphology (FBG) team which was used to finalise our Environment Agency planning response to the local authority.

No other comments or advice in respect of salmonid impacts have been provided to local authority at this stage.

The FBG Team’s responses to the local planning authority (LPA) regarding the proposed scheme covered a range of aspects.  While the responses did not necessarily detail specific risks posed by individual elements of the scheme to each species / life stages concerned, we are fully aware of the potential impacts, including from the proposed discharges, and they actively inform our position from a FBG perspective.  Furthermore, both the LPA and the applicant have been made aware that UK BAP priority fish species (which are among the most threatened and require conservation action) inhabit the Bedburn Beck system. They know the system is widely used by salmonids for spawning and that these fish are sensitive to impacts, particularly pollution.


4. Flow and water-quality information:
Existing flow data, hydrological information, model inputs, assumptions, outputs or reviews held by the EA that relate to assessing the proposed discharges at the Bedburn and Euden receiving watercourses. This includes any recorded low-flow or Q95 information and any Monte Carlo modelling already undertaken or reviewed for this proposal. I am not asking the EA to carry out new modelling.

Our Hydrology Team was not consulted as part of this planning application; therefore we do not hold any information in respect of the assessment of the proposed discharges. Assessment of the hydrological impacts of a discharge would only be undertaken once a discharge permit application had been received.

Our Fisheries, Biodiversity and Geomorphology Team will better assess the potential impacts on salmonids once an EPR application is submitted, and our Permitting Team will model the effects of the proposed discharges to the watercourses concerned.


5. Reasons salmonid protection measures remain undetermined:
Records identifying or discussing proposed construction restrictions, operational controls, monitoring requirements, thresholds or corrective actions to protect salmonid habitat. Please also provide any recorded reasons or advice explaining why these measures “have yet to be determined”, including any records showing whether this is because:
- further or more complete information from the applicant is required;
- the EA expects the measures to be determined through environmental permitting; or
- another reason applies.
I am seeking existing records that address this issue, not a newly created explanation or assessment.

From a FBG perspective, the “salmonid protection measures remain undetermined” for all the above reasons.  As we are currently objecting to the planning application, we do not know what the final submission will be, so cannot take a view on what appropriate protection measures would be.  It is not our role to identify or design appropriate measures; it is our role to assess whether the measures proposed by the applicant are appropriate.


6. Environmental-permitting process:
Records held by the EA of any environmental-permit application or pre-application engagement concerning the proposed discharges, including its status as at 19 October 2026 and any recorded advice about the information or modelling required to assess them.
The request covers relevant records held by the EA’s fisheries, water-quality, hydrology, planning and permitting teams, including relevant correspondence with the applicant, its consultants or Durham County Council.
I am seeking existing recorded information, not the creation of new data, analysis or an assessment. If any item is not held, please confirm that. If the EA considers any part unclear or too broad, please contact me under Regulation 9 so that I can clarify or narrow it. If information is withheld, please identify the exception relied on and provide the required explanation.

Please note that we have not received any permit application for this site so far and the enclosed documents were submitted to support pre-application advice requests. The purpose of the pre-application process is to obtain early regulatory advice and clarify potential permitting requirements. Information provided at this stage is not subject to the same level of technical review, assessment or determination as information submitted with a formal permit application. As a result, the documents reflect information supplied by the applicant and should not be interpreted as representing a formal Environment Agency assessment or decision.

Please refer to the Open Government Licence which explains the permitted use of the information attached.

Please note that personal data has been redacted from the information.

As a public body under FOI / EIR we must provide reasons for refusing to provide information, please refer to the appendix below for further details.

Information not held

EIR Regulation 3(2) states that information is held if it is in our possession and has been produced or received by us, or it is held by another person on our behalf at the time the request is received.

Where a request is for environmental information, the Regulations allow us to refuse to disclose it if the exception at EIR Regulation 12(4)(a) applies. The regulation states that a public authority may refuse to disclose environmental information to the extent that it does not hold that information when an applicant’s request is received. 

In this case, some of the information you have requested is not held by the Environment Agency. Therefore, we are refusing the following elements of your request on the grounds that there is no information we can provide:

1) Information documenting the fishery specialist’s review of the proposed discharges.

2) Records documenting how the EA considered effects on spawning adults, eggs, alevins, fry, parr and migrating smolts, and the information it relied on about known or likely spawning areas near each proposed discharge.

3) Assessment of the hydrological impacts of the proposed discharges.

4) Records identifying or discussing proposed construction restrictions, operational controls, monitoring requirements, thresholds or corrective actions to protect salmonid habitat.

It is not possible for us to conduct a public interest balancing test because the reason for non-disclosure is that the information is not held.

Rights of appeal

If you are not satisfied with our decision, you can contact us within two calendar months to ask for the decision to be reviewed. We will then conduct an internal review of our response to your request and give you our decision in writing within 40 working days.

To contact us, please reply directly to this email and quote the Case reference for this request - EIR2026/52043.

If you are not satisfied with the outcome of the internal review, you can then make an appeal to the Information Commissioner Office, the statutory regulator for the Environmental Information Regulations 2004 and the Freedom of Information Act 2000. Please follow this link to the ICO online complaints portal. The address is: Information Commissioner's Office, Wycliffe House, Water Lane, Wilmslow, Cheshire. SK9 5AF.

Tel: 0303 123 1113 (local rate) or 01625 545 745 (national rate) | Fax: 01625 524 510 Email: icocasework@ico.org.uk | Website: www.ico.org.uk

 Appendix 

The Environment Agency is not able to provide third party names, contact details and signatures as this is personal data under the Data Protection Act 2018 (DPA 2018) and to disclose it would breach the First Data Protection Principle of the DPA 2018.

The information requested is therefore exempt due to Regulation 13(1) of the Environmental Information Regulations 2004, which explains that:

“To the extent that the information requested includes personal data of which the applicant is not the data subject, a public authority must not disclose the personal data if—

1.       the first condition is satisfied…”

The ‘first condition’ referred to above is further explained in Regulation 13(2A):

“The first condition is that the disclosure of the information to a member of the public otherwise than under these Regulations—

1.       would contravene any of the data protection principles…”

The First Data Protection Principle requires that we are fair to individuals when we collect and use their personal data. In this case it would be unfair to disclose information relating to an identifiable individual as such individuals have a reasonable expectation that any information held about them by the Environment Agency would remain confidential. 

We have withheld the name of an Environment Agency employee under Regulation 13(1)(a) of the Environmental Information Regulations 2004.

This information constitutes personal data. Having considered the employee's role, responsibilities and reasonable expectations of privacy, we have concluded that disclosing their identity would be unfair and would contravene the data protection principles under Article 5(1)(a) of the UK GDPR.

 The Public Interest Test

 There is no requirement to conduct a public interest test when withholding personal data.

Documents

This is Environment Agency's response to a freedom of information (FOI) or environmental information regulations (EIR) request.

You can browse our other responses or make a new FOI request.