impact of the proposed eastgate lithium development on water supplies at Lintzgarth
Case reference EIR2026/54978
Received 21 October 2026
Published 18 November 2026
Request
I am writing to raise concerns about the potential impact of the proposed Eastgate lithium extraction development on the natural springs on which we depend.
Our house relies entirely on a natural spring behind the property for all our drinking and domestic water. Several additional springs run through our land, supplying our livestock and feeding into our fields, some of which contain rare upland haymeadows with natural springs within them.
I am concerned about the potential effects of groundwater abstraction and reinjection associated with the development on spring flow, groundwater levels and water quality, and the possible consequences for our household, livestock, agricultural land and sensitive habitats.
I would be grateful if you could clarify the following:
1. Groundwater assessment: Have our springs and their groundwater catchments been specifically identified and included in the project's hydrogeological and environmental risk assessments?
2. Potential impacts: What investigations, pumping tests and groundwater modelling have been undertaken to assess the potential effects on spring flow, water availability and water quality in the Rookhope area?
3. Protection and monitoring: What measures will be implemented to protect private drinking water supplies, livestock water sources and the springs supporting our haymeadows? Will baseline water quality and flow measurements be established before operations commence or groundwater abstraction increases?
4. Contingency arrangements: If the development adversely affects our water supply or land, who will be responsible for investigating the cause and providing an adequate alternative water supply or appropriate remedial measures?
5. Environmental protection: Have the rare upland haymeadows and their associated springs been assessed for potential impacts arising from changes in groundwater levels, spring flow or water quality?
Given our complete reliance on these natural springs, I believe it is essential that their protection is properly considered before the development proceeds. Any reduction in water availability or deterioration in quality could have serious consequences for our household, livestock and the ecological condition of our land.
I would appreciate a written response addressing these concerns, together with copies of, or links to, any relevant hydrogeological assessments, monitoring data and proposed protective measures.
I would also welcome advice on establishing an accurate baseline record of our springs' flow and water quality, and confirmation of whether independent testing and ongoing monitoring will be made available to potentially affected landowners.
Response
We refer to your request for information regarding impact of the Proposed Eastgate Lithium Development on Water Supplies at Lintzgarth, which we received on 21 October 2026.
We have noted that your email contains both a request for information under the EIR and general enquiries. We have addressed these separately below.
General enquiry response
Prior to operation of any of the proposed lithium extraction schemes operators will need to apply to us for several licences and permits.
As part of this regulatory process each operator will need to demonstrate to us via sufficient risk assessment that their activities will not pose a risk to water supplies and water dependent features across the area.
Any risks identified would require suitable mitigation measures to be identified. The need for monitoring and mitigation limits and conditions to be included in any subsequent abstraction licence or environmental permit will be determined if applications are validated and progress towards determination and issue.
It would be the requirement of the operator to undertake any required monitoring - this could include measurement of water flows and volumes, water quality and water levels and borehole pressures. We cannot state what monitoring would be required at this time as no licences or permits have been issued however monitoring at the point of any abstraction and reinjection boreholes is expected to be a requirement for any lithium brine extraction scheme.
We do not dual regulate and would look to address these risks via our licensing and permitting process rather than via planning. Any risks to water supplies or water dependent features that fall outside of our regulatory remit and cannot be covered by licence or permit limits/conditions we would look to address via the planning process.
We have been consulted by Durham County Council on the recent Northern Lithium planning application. We have recommended several planning conditions be imposed to any planning approval to manage any risks which may fall outside of our regulation, these primarily relate to borehole decommissioning, shallow pipework design and standard pollution prevention measures. Our response, once sent, should be available to view on the Council’s planning portal with all of the submitted reports and risk assessments.
At this time, we are not in a position to confirm whether your supply has been included in any of the risk assessments submitted for either the planning application or the licence and permit applications. We would look to address risks to water users in the catchment via our licensing and permitting process rather than via planning. As present no applications for the proposed scheme have been validated or progressed for technical review by any company.
Weardale Lithium has undertaken only a small amount of testing to date via a Groundwater Investigation Consent, we have not received any risk assessment reports for this system as yet via our permitting process.
Northern Lithium has undertaken a series of pumping tests to date covered by Groundwater Investigation Consents, the most recent being a 60 day pumping and tracer test. The primary aim of the test was to determine flow mechanisms between the pilot abstraction and reinjection boreholes. Good connectivity between the boreholes at depth was proven. No impact to the shallow groundwater was observed during any of the testing to date. Further groundwater risks assessments will be required as part of licence and permit applications.
There are several methods for monitoring springs including simply measuring how long it takes to fill a container of a given size to installing a v-notch weir or flume or installing flow metering equipment, we are unable to provide advice on which would be the best method for monitoring the flow of your spring. To determine a good baseline, we would always recommend a minimum of 6-12 months water level or flow monitoring to account for season changes. Ideally monitoring should cover a significant dry period and a significant wet period to determine natural and highs and lows.
We would also recommend several water quality samples are obtained to determine baseline chemistry. Chemical analysis should be determined by taking account of the expected natural quality of the groundwater in the area e.g. of the Carboniferous Limestone and of any potential pollutants. The baseline reports produced by the British Geological Survey (BGS) may be useful, they can be found at: https://www.bgs.ac.uk/groundwater/quality/baseline-chemistry-uk-aquifers/baseline-reports/england-and-wales/
The Environment Agency would investigate any pollution incident reported through our National Incident Hotline and take appropriate regulatory action where necessary. We would also investigate any suspected non-compliance with licence or permit conditions and take action as appropriate. Responsibility for any necessary remedial or mitigation measures would be determined through the investigation.
Request for information under the Environmental Information Regulations response
Regarding your request for copies of, or links to, any relevant hydrogeological assessments, monitoring data and proposed protective measures, we are handling your request for information under the Environmental Information Regulations 2004 (EIR) as we have determined it to be a request for 'environmental information'.
We regret that we are unable to respond to your request as currently worded. We are refusing your request under EIR regulation 12(4)(c) which states that a public authority may refuse requests that are ‘formulated in too general a manner’ (e.g. a request that is unclear, non-specific or is open to more than one interpretation).
Regulation 9 - Advice and Assistance
In line with regulation 9(2) if a request has been formulated in too general a manner, then a public authority is required to provide advice and assistance to the customer to rephrase or clarify their request.
We want to be as open as possible in answering requests, and to help you obtain the information you are looking for. To help you to submit a new, revised request for information that will enable us to understand what information you are seeking; please can you advise further regarding the following:
· Confirmation of whether you are solely looking for final hydrogeological or groundwater risk assessments including mitigation or are you looking for any risk assessment document that we hold
· Confirmation of the activities and/or receptors at risk you are enquiring about e.g. groundwater features only
· The specific type(s) of monitoring data you are requesting
You may find it helpful to browse through our Data Services Platform environment.data.gov.uk/ which contains Environment Agency published data as this may help you to clarify your request.
Public Interest Test
The application of Regulation 12(4)(c) is subject to the public interest test which requires us to balance the public interest factors in favour of disclosing the information against those for in favour of maintaining the exception. Despite the general public interest in making information available on request, and the Environment Agency’s commitment to openness and transparency, we find that in this instance the public interest in disclosure is outweighed by the need to deploy our resources in the most effective manner, and not to spend large amounts of time on unclear requests.
Rights of appeal
If you are not satisfied with our decision, you can contact us within two calendar months to ask for the decision to be reviewed. We will then conduct an internal review of our response to your request and give you our decision in writing within 40 working days.
To contact us, please reply directly to this email and quote the Case reference for this request - EIR2026/54978.
If you are not satisfied with the outcome of the internal review, you can then make an appeal to the Information Commissioner Office, the statutory regulator for the Environmental Information Regulations 2004 and the Freedom of Information Act 2000. Please follow this link to the ICO online complaints portal. The address is: Information Commissioner's Office, Wycliffe House, Water Lane, Wilmslow, Cheshire. SK9 5AF.
Tel: 0303 123 1113 (local rate) or 01625 545 745 (national rate) | Fax: 01625 524 510 Email: icocasework@ico.org.uk | Website: www.ico.org.uk
Documents
This is Environment Agency's response to a freedom of information (FOI) or environmental information regulations (EIR) request.
You can browse our other responses or make a new FOI request.